• 26 Posts
  • 361 Comments
Joined 5 months ago
cake
Cake day: May 16th, 2026

help-circle















  • Who else advocates for “West Asia”? Is it just Iran?

    There was a really insane dude I ran into somewhere on the internet that would just always talk about how great Persia was and was always bringing up the Persian Empire and talking about how Persian armies defeated Rome or Greece (aka The West) in this or that battle–totally out of context–so I know what you’re talking about.

    Oh, and the Iranian guy who uses “West Asia”, also refers to “The West,” meaning Europe and the US, so I guess everyone falls into geographical relativitity eventually.


  • Generally, I like colloquial terms to stay colloquial and scientific terms to stay scientific. I am not going to correct someone for calling a mountain goat a goat–looks like a goat, acts like a goat, close enough, but don’t say it’s in Capra.

    For me, I’m perfectly happy defining landmasses by conjoined areas on a map, with the only real sticking point being how small a landmass is small enough to discount as conjoining (North and South America). That’s based on objective physical fact; how those facts are interpreted would be a matter of consensus, of course, but the problem set is much more simplified.

    This is kind of related to the whole Pluto debate. “Planet” is a word that has popular meaning, but we all kind of agree that astronomy gets to be the ultimate arbiter. “Continent” has no such committee.


  • Meh. More like I don’t think I’m supposed to be calling it the Middle East without seeming like an imperialist and I don’t want to call it West Asia because I don’t like Europe being a continent, so I’m kinda stuck.

    I’m also wondering how people interpret “Middle East”, because I’m sensitive to that shit, especially on a global website. Like I don’t want to be calling placed “third world” if that’s offensive to people in the developing world / global south / ???.

    “Middle East” is what I’ve always known the region as, and it’s just a historical-cultural accident that, in my defense, makes just as much sense as separating Europe from Asia. So either we keep both ME and Europe, or we get rid of both, is my logic.

    So do I have agenda? Sort of. But also just wondering what people’s thoughts are on the subject.

    One of my recent posts here was, “What’s a very specific opinion you have phrased as a question?” in homage to that evergreen and annoying problem of push polling on question forums.